Options
Does method matter? An experiment on collaborative business model idea generation in teams
Journal
Innovation: Management, policy & practice
ISSN
1447-9338
Type
journal article
Date Issued
2012-09
Author(s)
Hoffmann, Friederike
Abstract
The development of new business models presents a critical and demanding task for organizations. Among other things, the task requires effective divergent and convergent group processes. A growing body of theoretical literature and empirical evidence shows that artifacts can support collaboration, creativity, and innovation in groups. Such artifacts include visual templates, physical objects, and sketches. Based on existing theories on idea generation and boundary objects, this proposal explains how artifacts can facilitate the development of new business model ideas in teams. Specifically, this paper hypothesizes that artifacts have an impact on perceived group collaboration, perceived creativity, and the decision to adopt a new business model idea. The model was tested with an initial experimental study with managers who were asked to develop innovative business models for a daily newspaper, working under one of three different conditions. The subjects worked in groups and were assigned to either: (1) an empty PowerPoint slide (control group); (2) physical objects combined with sketching; or (3) a visual business model template in a software environment. The results of this pilot study indicate that using a digital visual business model template significantly increases perceived collaboration and actually decreases perceived creativity and the willingness to adopt the business model idea generated. Physical objects combined with sketching do not yield results distinct from the control condition of filling out an empty slide. These results provide initial empirical evidence that artifacts have the power to shape the group process of developing new business models, and that the proposed model can capture relevant dimensions of how they affect such a process.
Language
English
Keywords
innovation
business model
idea generation
collaboration
artifact
boundary objects
visualization
HSG Classification
contribution to scientific community
Refereed
Yes
Publisher
eContent Management
Publisher place
Maleny
Volume
14
Number
3
Start page
388
End page
403
Pages
16
Subject(s)
Division(s)
Eprints ID
211575